Tonight was one of the most uninspiring final 3 performances that I can remember. It’s not like it was horrible. It just wasn’t fabulous. Since this was supposed to be the best American Idol pool ever, I really expected more. The singers sang three songs tonight: one chosen by a judge, one they chose themselves, and one chosen by the producers.
David Archuleta started the night with “And So It Goes”, chosen by Paula. It was definitely his best song of the night. I think it was helped by the fact that I didn’t know the song, so I couldn’t be annoyed by his drawing out of the song. Randy gave the usual, predictable “dope, in it to win it” critique. Simon said it was very good but predictable. Next, he departed completely from his usual song style and chose to sing Chris Brown’s “With You”. Yeah, that was pretty horrible. Randy was right on when he said it was not believable hearing David sing to “Boo”. It was really just bizarre. Simon’s imagery was pretty good when he said it was like “a chihuahua trying to be a tiger”. It was the high school talent show performance of the song. I don’t know what he was thinking with that song choice. I guess it was a slightly more appropriate song choice than “Brick House”, but it’s a toss up. His final song was chosen by the producers. They chose “Longer”, which was certainly a more appropriate song choice. However, he reverted to the squinty eyed sincere look, but he sounded okay. He hit all the notes, and it was okay, although not remarkable.
Randy chose Syesha Mercado’s first song, “If I Ain’t Got You”. It sounded good, but I don’t really have anything super positive or horribly negative tosay about it. There was nothing wrong with it. It just wasn’t wonderful. For her second song, Syesha chose to sing “Fever”. The judges panned this choice, but I thought it was a good choice for her. It reminded me of a Broadway audition, which is pretty much how I think Syesha should view her time on American Idol. Paula, who had just defended David A’s choice of “With You” chose to say it didn’t really show who she was. Really, Paula? Whereas David A’s choice showed exactly who he is? Seriously? The producers’ song choice seemed to definitely indicate who they want to see in the finale. They chose “Hit Me Up”, which was a fun, upbeat song but didn’t do anything for Syesha. It did, however, allow the judges to engage in a 5 minute discussion about Happy Feet— odd, since the show was put out by competing studio Warner Brothers. Maybe Warner Brothers paid for it.
David Cook was the last singer of the night. Simon chose for him to sing “First Time Ever I Saw Your Face”. I really thought Simon would have chosen something more upbeat. I do think he was looking to see what David would do with the song. He did an interesting marriage of the original with a bit of originality towards the end. His voice sounded great. Randy wanted a rock song, so he was disappointed (maybe Randy should have chosen David C’s song). Simon thought it was one of his best performances (not that he’s biased). When it came time to choose his own song, David chose something that sounded more like what I would expect him to sing, “Dare You To Move”. I was afraid he would choose something really bizarre, but this was a good song choice. It showed his range, allowed him to sing something unknown but wasn’t so far out there that it would wig out the American Idol viewers. Finally, the producers gave David “Don’t Want to Miss a Thing”. It was an okay song choice, allowing him to show the rock side and ballad side simultaneously. The last note was a bit sketchy, though. It was enough to encourage Simon to declare him the winner of the night, though.
So, it looks like a Davids finale, as it has looked for weeks. Hopefully, David Archuleta will pull of the finale and allow David Cook to come in second and pursue his own contract negotiations and to make his own album. David A. is perfectly suited to reign as American Idol winner.
