In this round both sang an original song, ostensibly one that was written for them. Katharine’s song was boring, in my opinion. It was just not that interesting, and the judges agreed. Randy and Paula thought her performance of the song was good, but I thought it was just okay. Simon also thought it was just okay.

Taylor’s song was better. What I really liked about this is exactly what Randy really liked. Any song Taylor sings sounds like a “Taylor Hicks” song. Do I think it’s the best song ever written? No. I haven’t heard any American Idol finale song that I wanted to run out and buy the single. I thought it was a really good performance, though.

The show closed out with Daniel Powter playing “Bad Day” while a montage of scenes from the entire season played on the big screen. So, the question is who will be having a bad day tomorrow?

Off to vote. Happy dialing!

No tags