I was really shocked that Mandisa didn’t know who Barry Manilow was— didn’t know AT ALL? How is that possible? He’s Barry Manilow. Other than that, I thought Mandisa’s performance last night was her best yet. And is it just me, or has she lost weight?

I thought Bucky Covington sounded okay, but I did not really enjoy the performance of the song. Simon thought theperformance was “nothing more than a pointless karaoke performance.” I thought that was a bit harsh, but I agreed that it wasn’t that great a performance. I thought it was the weakest of the night.

I don’t really have anything additional to add about Paris Bennett’s performance. She was very good. Barry thought so, and the judges thought so.

I mentioned that I found Chris Daughtry’s performance a bit boring. I thought it was good. And I appreciate that Chris “knows who he is”, as Simon is so fond of saying. But I just think it’s kind of like hearing him sing the same song every week. I like a little more variety.

I thought Katharine McPhee’s song choice was not the best for her. Simon loved it and thought that she was “a star”. I hope, for Katharine’s sake, that my trend with the “I just don’t get what the judges are raving about” songs doesn’t hold true. I didn’t get the fuss over Melissa, and she went home. And I like Katharine, so I’d like to see her continue to be around.

I loved that Barry Manilow thought Taylor Hicks was one of the best male vocalists in the show. I agree, Barry, I agree. I think someone’s been working with Taylor. It was still unique but less spastic.

I don’t know what else to say about Lisa Tucker. It was a cute, decent performance. Unfortunately for her, there were many performances that were much better than that.

So, supposedly Kevin Covais just broke up with a long term girlfriend, and they’re still such great friends that they still talk every day, but he gives us the “Aw shucks, I’m just a sweet kid still waiting to fall in love” routine. Hmmm. Wonder how the ex-girlfriend feels to find out she’s not his first love. Or is this just more manipulation of his female fans? I do have to say that this week’s performance was better than last week, but honestly I just don’t see how anyone could think there were three performers that performed worse, so that Kevin should avoid the bottom three.

I thought that after Barry Manilow worked with Elliott Yamin that Elliott sounded a bit like Barry at the beginning of the song, in particular—not that that’s a bad thing. Why did Elliott look so different this week? I couldn’t really put my finger on exactly what was different, but something definitely looked different. Anyone have any ideas?

I was glad that Kellie Pickler was back to singing country. I thought it was a good performance. I’m partial to Patsy Cline singing Patsy Cline, so I didn’t think it was out of this world, but I thought it was good. She seemed stressed, though. Particularly when they first walked out. Is all of this just a bit too much for Kellie?

When Barry Manilow said that he’d encouraged Ace Young to sing in falsetto, I screamed “NOOOOOO!” at the television. What is up with falsetto in this year’s competition. I hate it. Ugh. But last night it was only the last note, and it was fine and appropriate. I should have known Barry wouldn’t be wrong. I find a disconnect between the sexy image they try to have Ace portray and what I think is his true personality. He seems painfully shy to me and when they to portray him as the Constantine of this year, I just don’t buy it.

SPEAKING OF CONSTANTINE….

Did you see him? It was the highlight of the show for me. It would only have been better if they let him sing.

Well, that’s the wrap up. I’ll be back tonight to share in the agony and exultation of elimination night. See you then.