So, tonight was the big night— American Idol sings Queen. For better or for worse, this was it.

The night started with Bucky Covington. I thought this was going to be a disaster, to be honest. But you know what? It wasn’t half bad. Bucky sang Fat Bottomed Girls, and it kind of reminded me of any number of southern rock bands. It was really decent, and I enjoyed it.

Ace Young sang “We Will Rock You”. It was, um, not good. There was a very awkward moment when Ace tried to tell Queen how the song should be rewritten, and they refused to sing it that way. Ace? It’s “We Will Rock You”. If you can’t sing it the way it’s written, you probably just shouldn’t sing it. I think this will be Ace’s last chance. I don’t think even the pretty boy vote will save him.

When I heard that Kellie Pickler was going to sing “Bohemian Rhapsody”, I thought, “ugh”. It wasn’t fabulous, in my opinion. Kellie wearing all black leather biker gear was a bit odd to me, but while it wasn’t my favorite performance of “Bohemian Rhapsody”, it wasn’t terrible, either. I don’t really know what to make of it. I have a feeling that die-hard Queen fans will hate it, but do die-hard Queen fans really watch American Idol? The judges seemed to enjoy it, as well.

I initially thought that Chris Daughtry’s decision to sing “Innuendo”, a song that Queen never performed in public, was genius. And then he sang the song. I have to agree with Simon’s assessment— the reason Queen has never sung the song is that it’s not a very good song. You all know by now that I don’t really like the screaming thing. But my husband does. And HE didn’t like this performance, either. He really likes Chris, but he didn’t enjoy tonight.

Katharine McPhee was the first of two singers to change her song. When she sang with Queen, she was singing “Don’t Stop Me Now”, but she decided to change the song, which I think was a good idea because she looked a bit too perky and just a bit strange singing that particular Queen song. Instead, she chose to sing “Who Wants To Live Forever” from the Highlander soundtrack. I love Highlander, and I really like that song, but this performance qualified for my “What were the judges listening to?” performance tonight. I thought it was decent. I didn’t hate it, but I didn’t think it was as good as the judges. I just thought she didn’t really do justice to Freddie Mercury.

I thought Elliott Yamin’s “Somebody to Love” was the best performance of the night. Now, I still find Elliott a bit awkward to watch sometime, but when I closed my eyes and just listened to the song, I thought he was the only one who really came close to singing Queen in a manner consistent with Freddie Mercury. Now, that’s not to say that I thought he was “imitating” Freddie Mercury, I just thought he sounded really, really good singing this song.

Then came Taylor Hicks. In case you’re just tuning in Taylor Hicks is my favorite American Idol contestant. Taylor was the second contestant to change his song. He was supposed to be singing “We Are the Champions”, but I think he, also, made a good decision to change songs. Not that he didn’t sound good singing “We Are the Champions”, but it’s a pretty sedate song and really hard to get a big reaction out of an audience, unless you’re at a prom/championship sporting event/etc. So, he switched to “Crazy Little Thing Called Love”, the most Elvis sounding Queen song ever written. I thought it was great. It was fun, it made me smile, it was entertaining. Randy and Paula liked it. Simon thought it was weird, asking Taylor if he was drunk. Whatever, Simon…

The closing number tonight was Paris Bennett, singing “The Show Must Go On”. It was a really interesting look for Paris, kind of a Janet Jackson thing. Queen LOVED Paris, by the way. I thought this performance was good. I wish Chris had chosen to sing something like this. You know— the big rock anthem. Anyway, Randy and Paula liked this, but Simon just thought it was odd. I think it’s just because Simon likes Paris to look like a little girl. He doesn’t like it when she dresses and sings “too old”. But she’s not twelve.

So, that was Queen night. I was entertained, for the most part. I think Ace Young will go home, but who else will be in the bottom three? I really think it will most likely be Katharine and possibly Bucky (even though I enjoyed his performance). I’d put Chris in the bottom three, as far as my favorites tonight, but I don’t think that’s going to happen. So, I think it will probably be Bucky or Kellie (depending on how much people really hated that performance of “Bohemian Rhapsody”).