The group performance tonight was not as bad as usual. Interestingly enough, I thought the group had more fun singing Dolly Parton’s 9-5 than anything else this season.
Ryan called out the first three individually: Michael Johns— safe; David Archuleta— safe; Carly Smithson— safe.
Then we had questions from callers, none of which were all that interesting. It was kind of funny to hear Michael Johns and David Cook facetiously talking about singing a duet of “Islands in the Stream”. Hey, if they can dance a “mango” on “Dancing With The Stars”, I suppose anything is possible.
Then they had The Clark Brothers on. I LOVE The Clark Brothers!! I used to rave about Ashley (the lead singer) when he was Carrie Underwood’s fiddler. And Austin, the brother who plays the weird looking guitar (called a dobro), was on with Kellie Pickler a couple of weeks ago. I just adore them and can’t wait for an album.
Next up was the Ford commercial, featuring “It’s Tricky”, which for some reason I found to be really funny.
Then it was back to the main event. David Cook was out. Ryan talked to him about his visit to the hospital, which turned out to be for high blood pressure. Thank goodness it was nothing more serious. Anyway, David was safe. Ramiele Malubay and Kristy Lee Cook came out (individually) and were both sent to the bottom three. Ramiele looked like a kicked puppy, and Kristy Lee could not have been less surprised.
There was a brief segment catching up with Idol contestants that have moved to Nashville: Bucky Covington, Phil Stacey, and Bo Bice.
Syesha came out next and was safe (which was surprising to me), leaving Brooke White and Jason Castro to fight it out for the final position in the bottom three. I assumed it would be Jason since he was in the bottom three last week, but NO— it was sweet, angelic Brooke. Shame on you America!
They left the three girls waiting FOREVER while they did an Idol Gives Back promo (coming up next week, you know) and Dolly Parton sang “Jesus and Gravity”. Finally, Brooke was declared safe, before Ramiele was sent home. I think that was the right decision, although there are several others I could have gone for just as easily.
What do you think? Justice served? Or is it a total travesty?
Well, we definitely differed in opinion of the show this week. I LOVED it!
Okay..first up..
Brook White with “Jolene”. I thought she did a very nice job. (But smiling as she did in parts may have made her performance seem insincere, as it is supposed to be “heart wrenching”, about a woman stealing her man!)
Next up, David Cook..
I expected him to pick Jolene (sung in the style of the White Stripes) but I’m REALLY glad he didn’t.
He picked an awesome song and really made it his own, and it was beautiful!! I LOVED it. And I totally disagree with Simon, I thought it was his BEST, most heartfelt performance thus far.
Next up, Ramiele.
This was probably the worst performance of the night. I don’t know what it is.. I know Ramiele has a big voice, but something about being on stage just swallows it up. She seems mediocre compared to the others in the competition. I think she may be leaving us tomorrow. Definitely in the bottom 3.
4th contestant up is Jason Castro.
I Loved his performance. (I understand that people may be getting sick of his style, but I’m not.) I just love a good, soulful acoustic..and he is good at what he does. I don’t think he is close to winning idol, but I for one, will buy his solo album!!
5th up.. Carly Smithson.
I think Carly is one of the best vocalists in the competition. Tonight was my favorite performance of hers so far. She changed the song up..she slowed it down and added her own flair to it.
6th up..Little Archuleta.
Not my favorite contestant by far, but he had very good vocals tonight. My problem with him is he is not original at all. He does not do anything to change up the song or give it his own little bit of spice.
Maybe he’s just too young… (But the young girls LOVE him!) He will be up in the “top 3” again this week.
7th..Kristy Lee Cook.
” I was so looking forward to seeing that actually happen! 
....I think that was barely a slight breeze..
Oh Kristy.. I expected you to “BLOW SIMON’S SOCKS OFF
If Kristy can’t even shine on “Country Night…” Her time is almost up.
I have to admit she sounded pretty good during practice with Dolly, but her performance on stage was not nearly as good..mediocre at best. She is in the bottom 3 for sure.
8th..Syesha.
I predicted either she or Ramiele would attempt the dreaded “I Will Always Love You”.
I have to admit she did a much better job than I ever expected. But I still am not liking this girl. She seems very phony. She didn’t sell it to me. It annoyed me that she started off her performance on top of a Grande Piano.. I’m surprised Simon didn’t call it indulgent. I think she will be in the bottom 3 as well.
9th… Michael Johns.
(Sorry…he’s been my favorite since day one) and tonight Michael has
AMAZING!! He gave us the low notes, the high notes and every note in between
That was SO GREAT!
The Best for last
proved he has the pipes
I’m so happy with this night. I thought it would be a complete disaster…but it has turned out to be
My favorite AI night so far this season.