American Idol
On Our TV

Who should be the next American Idol?
David Cook: 56% (87)
David Archuleta: 44% (69)
Total Votes : 156

Who do you want to win the finale?
David Archuleta: 48% (69)
David Cook: 52% (74)
Total Votes : 143

Who do you most want to see in the finale?
David Archuleta: 33% (18)
Syesha Mercado: 9% (5)
David Cook: 57% (31)
Total Votes : 54

Which performance was worse, Brooke singing “I’m a Believer” or Jason Castro singing “I Shot the Sheriff”?
Brooke: 13% (5)
Jason: 87% (33)
Total Votes : 38

Jason Castro singing “I Shot the Sheriff” (yes, that’s right when you get to the phone numbers, you can clearly see Jason mouth “Don’t vote!”):

Brooke White singing “I’m a Believer”:

Who was your favorite singer tonight?
David Cook: 28% (7)
Syesha Mercado: 16% (4)
Jason Castro: 12% (3)
David Archuleta: 44% (11)
Total Votes : 25

Should the winner of American Idol be the best “vocalist”?
Yes, singing is the most important: 53% (10)
No, singing is only part of the contest: 47% (9)
Total Votes : 19

Who will go home tomorrow night?
Jason Castro: 56% (9)
David Cook: 0% (0)
Brooke White: 31% (5)
David Archuleta: 0% (0)
Syesha Mercado: 12% (2)
Total Votes : 16

Did Carly deserve to go home?
Yes: 21% (5)
If not this week, then next: 12% (3)
Eventually: 62% (15)
No, she should have won: 4% (1)
Total Votes : 24

Who was your favorite singer tonight?
Michael Johns: 14% (10)
Syesha Mercado: 4% (3)
Jason Castro: 16% (11)
Kristy Lee Cook: 10% (7)
David Cook: 3% (2)
Carly Smithson: 4% (3)
David Archuleta: 46% (32)
Brooke White: 3% (2)
Total Votes : 70

Are you looking forward to Idol Gives Back next week?
Yes: 55% (17)
No: 45% (14)
Total Votes : 31

Who should go home this week?
Brooke White: 4% (2)
David Cook: 0% (0)
Ramiele Malubay: 56% (28)
Jason Castro: 6% (3)
Carly Smithson: 4% (2)
David Archuleta: 6% (3)
Kristy Lee Cook: 12% (6)
Syesha Mercado: 12% (6)
Michael Johns: 0% (0)
Total Votes : 50

While the length of time it takes to reveal the eliminated contestant isn’t the MOST bothersome thing to me, it’s definitely up there. And the phone calls from viewers this year are generally pretty lame. But the group song is still the most annoying thing to me, personally.

What is the most annoying thing about the results show?
The group song/medley: 7% (3)
The Ford commercial: 5% (2)
The promotion of Idol Gives Back: 5% (2)
The guest singer: 5% (2)
The length of time it takes to reveal the eliminated contestant: 35% (14)
The final performance by the eliminated contestant: 17% (7)
The phone calls from viewers: 25% (10)
Total Votes : 40

Who had the best performance tonight?
Ramiele Malubay: 11% (9)
Jason Castro: 0% (0)
Syesha Mercado: 2% (2)
Chikezie: 4% (3)
Brooke White: 6% (5)
Michael Johns: 12% (10)
Carly Smithson: 2% (2)
David Archuleta: 10% (8)
Kristy Lee Cook: 5% (4)
David Cook: 46% (37)
Total Votes : 80

What was your reaction to tonight’s elimination?
That stinks!: 18% (9)
I’m disappointed.: 24% (12)
I’m glad.: 18% (9)
That’s who I wanted to go home.: 40% (20)
Total Votes : 50